How good are you at spotting manipulated images?
In the second 6wks of this class we will be learning all about digitally altering images with PhotoShop... Here is a PREtest-
http://area.autodesk.com/fakeorfoto
..and then HONESTLY post your score as today's reaction-
also-
which ONE was the most difficult?
--------------------------------------------
HOW TO POST-
Click on the little dark blue link below that says THE NUMBER OF COMMENTS
(to the right of the TIME display).
A POP UP window will appear.
Type in your 3 sentence reply -
- END with your FIRST INITIAL, LAST NAME, and your PERIOD.
Type the Captcha Security Code, letters and numbers.
Select ANONYMOUS as your IDENTITY type.
Hit the PUBLISH button.
74 comments:
I got 9/12. The one of the bathroom is probably the hardest because that is the one you would not expect to be a fake because it is just a bathroom.
M Silva P.1
I am terrible at spotting altered images. I got half of them correct. I feel that nature/land photos are the hardest to tell if it's fake or real.
K.Derschmidt P.1
I got 8 out of 12. The most difficult was probably the stair case or the nature one with the river.
I got exactly half of them correct 6/12. I think he bug ones were difficult, and I couldn't tell that the bathroom one was photo-shopped at all. So i guess I'm pretty bad at this.
My score was 8 of out 12. The one I found the most difficult, was the one of the ladybug.
J.Richardson P.1
I'm okay at spotting manipulated photos. I scored a 7/12. The chair was the most difficult, I don't know where it could've been altered.
T. Losness, Period 1
I got 8 out of 12. The most difficult was probably the stair case or the nature one with the river.
S.Quintanilla Per 1
I got exactly half of them correct 6/12. I think he bug ones were difficult, and I couldn't tell that the bathroom one was photo-shopped at all. So i guess I'm pretty bad at this.
c.brewer p.1
5 out of 12
the animal ones were difficult !
I got 7/12 on the spotting. The hardest one was the last picture, the close up of the bugs face.
T.Horne p1
6/12 and the most difficult was probably the chair one because it looks really but its not. Knowing someone can take a picture that easy and make it look real is amazing!
H.Cooper Per.1
I got 9 out of 12. The most difficult one for me was the toy helicopter. I thought it looked real and didn't see were it was altered.
B. Watson Period: 1
I got an 8/12 on the test. I thought the one's with the white backgrounds could go either way. I just guessed on those and then did the best I could.
D. Riley P.1
the ones that made me take a second look were probably the most difficult , and the animal ones! i got a 5 out of 12 . this test is kinda cool.
A.Johnson P.1
I got 8 out of 12. The most difficult was probably the picture of the lake it looked like.
A.Deeds P.1
Score: 10/12
The most difficult photo i think to figure out if it was real or fake was the beer and the stairs.
-S.McQuown period 1
Well at first I was going to do it without looking at the directions, but once I did I knew what to look for and what the pictures of how they looked and set up so I got 12 out of 12.
I got 6/12 on the fake or photo challenge. I think that the hardest one to tell whether it was digitally altered or not was picture #10. the stairs seemed real to me and I couldn't see any mess ups or obvious edits in it.
M.Christensen
I got 7 correct. The one that was the hardest was the landscape one! It looked really real to me.
A.Champ P.1
I got 5/10. I think the hardest was the stairs.
-A. Haunschild Per. 1
well. I failed that test. i was so confident in my answers too! they were very convincing.
t.hess p.1
I got almost every single one wrong, so i retook the test like three more times, and I still couldn't get it all correct. I could not find any obvious mistakes, which is really good for the photographer. They all looked realistic to me!
E.zitzelberger P.1
I got 5/10 so I failed. I think the hardest was the bathroom because it looks so real.
S. Matheson Period. 1
I got 9/12. I really couldn't tell on some of them so i guessed on a few.
K. Nagel P.2
I got 7/12. The ones that I got wrong, I had no idea if they were fake or not.
K.Seibold P.2
7/10
The bathroom shot was hard for me
A.Thomson P.2
I got 5 of the photos correct. I honestly can't really tell what photos are fixed or are normal.
M McClure P 2
Booo I got nine out of twelve. I think the most difficult one is the bathroom because I thought it was real.
A.Willis P.2
The bathroom and the stair case was the most hardest to figure out. I wouldn't think that the bathroom would be fake. The stairs look real to. i dont have a good eye for these kind of things.
T.Beard Per.2
I couldn't really tell on most if them. I only got a 5
T.Fryett P.2
The bathroom and the stair case was the most hardest to figure out. I wouldn't think that the bathroom would be fake. The stairs look real to. i dont have a good eye for these kind of things.
T.Beard Per.2
The most difficult one was the staircase photo. I got 5 out of 12 as my score.
B. Ennis Period 2
I got a six out of twelve.
I think that the ladybug one is the hardest to choose whether it was faked or not.
Ian M-W
Period 2
I got 7/12. I guessed on a lot of them. I couldn't really tell on some of the pictures.
C.Rankin
P.2
I could NEVER ever be a critic of realness of a photo. I fsiled the test of the test thing... and it was kinda tough to tell...
A.Lindberg P.2
I got 7 out of 12. I thought the frog was fake because it was like in a white background.
A.boland p.2
I got 6\12 the first time. I kept taking the test to try and get 100%. The hardest ones were the helicopter and stairs.
A.Herberger p.2
The hardest on is probably the airplane one, because it wouldn't open up on my computer. I got 10/12 on this.
J Meier
I thought i was pretty good until i toke that little test thing.. My score was 6 out of 12. The chair was probably the hardest one to determine.
M.Preston P.2
I think all these pictures look real. When the pictures are taken as close as they are they look really good. I would rate these photos a 10 out of 10.
T.Fischer Period:2
I only got 4 right out of all. I thought that the bug pictures were the hardest to determine if they were real. I thought they were real because I would think they would be hard to MAKE fake.
G. Williams P.2
I think the bathroom one was the hard one. All of these photos were hard to judge. I think these photos are cool.
I got 100%, The helicopter was definitely the hardest. Plastic seems so fake anyway so when you have to see if it is computer or if it is real it is hard. The animals were also hard since they had white backgrounds and could have been photoshopped in.
D.Jansen P.2
I got 8/12 Correct, the River was the easiest to tell, the ladybug shot I couldn't tell so I guessed n got it wrong sadly
~C. West
I got 3 out of 12. I couldn't really tell the difference that well. I look forward to learn about it.
T. Tinker P.2
I got 6. It was really hard for me to tell if they were real of fake.
M Melhus P. 2
My score was that i got 5 wrong. and it was really hard for me to tell which was which. But that just goes to show how talented people are :)
A.Sprague p. 2
I did terrible with this i got 5/12 right. i think the animal ones were the hardest ones to figure out because computer graphics have improved so much.
I got 5 out of 12. The hardest was the glass of whatever drink that is.
R.Simmons
Period 3
I didnt do very well, I got 7 out of 12! Not really sure which one was the "hardest".
K.Kruger Per.3
i got 2 wrong and I though the bathroom was confusing
k.polkk period3
I got 8/12 right. I think the animal ones were the hardest ones to figure out because they were so edited.
M Cordill. Per 3
I got 10/12. and i think that the stairs was the hardest to do. And it just shows what people can do with a computer.
S.Snyder P.3
I got 9 out of 12. The hardest one i think was the fake helicopter one.
D.Podloujnyi
Per.3
I got 10/12
The beetles were the hardest I think,The position and setup looks fake, but the reflection adds a sort of realistic scenario, But if you look closely its the photographer I think.
J. Brady per.6
I got 5/12. They were all pretty hard and I basically just guessed on all of them.
E.Wymore Period 3
I got 9 out of 12! I thought the hardest question was the picture of the bathroom. It looked real but I guess it was fake.
R.Jacobs P.3
I got 7/12. The most difficult one for me was probably the bathroom one. It doesn't look fake to me at all.
S. Kutsch per 3.
I got 7/12.I think that the bathroom picture or the pizzaria picture are the hardest to find out.
B Little Per.3
I got 6/12. I honestly think the stairs was the hardest because it looked so really. It shows how people can make pictures look so real but are actually fake.
S.Orozco P.3
I got 9 out of 12 correct. The hardest one was the bathroom picture. I had to look a couple times to be sure.
E. Angier P.3
I got 7 out of 12 right. The locations like the alley way was the hardest because they look real and you cant really tell if its had something added into the dark.
R. Drake Period 3
I did alright with this. I got 6/12. I think the most difficult were the nature shots, the were hard to tell.
J. Gallagher Per.3
I got 7 out of 12. Some of them were hard but the hardest was the landscape. I thought it could of been real.
L.Katzberg Period 3
I got 9/12. I think the hardest one was the last one with the close up bug and all the background was blurred, I got it right but it was a guess.
B. Leonetti Per 3
I got four right. The hardest one was the lady bug one. Next time I will pay more attention.
A.Stumbaugh P3
On the quiz i got 6/12. Some of the photos fooled me well. THey were nice pictures and couldnt tell what was what.
T.Munoz per.3
i got 10 out of 12 i got the helicopter and the bathroom wrong i thought they were both real. some of the photos looked so convincing that they were real.
B.Nowland P.3
The test was kind of hard. The hardest one was the stairs. The easiest one was the picture of the alley.
D Guisinger
P.3
i got 6/12, i found it really hard to tell a fake photo and a real photo apart. and the ones that i thought were real wernt and the ones that i got right were just lucky guesses. the hardest was the photo of the bathroom. the only thing that i thought that could be photoshoped in that picture would be the lighting.
J.Benjamin
I got 8 out of 12. The easiest was the creak and trees. The hardest would be either the bench or the frog.
S. Jost Per 3
I got 7/12 on the spotting. The hardest one was the close up on the bugs face.
I got 7/12 on the spotting. The hardest one was the close up on the bugs face.
S. Lovell
P2
9/12 was my final score. most of them were hard to find out the fake between the real. The one of the frog was the hardest to figure out.
J.Martin per.1
Post a Comment